Professional perspective
Clinical relevance
- Caries diagnosis and risk assessment (ICDAS system)
- Non-invasive and micro-invasive caries management (infiltration, remineralization)
- Fissure sealants for caries-susceptible molars
- Caries prevention in pediatric dentistry
- Caries prophylaxis in elevated-risk groups (xerostomia, diabetes, oncology patients, orthodontic patients)
- Root caries in older adults
Clinical implications
Distinguishing active from arrested lesions is clinically important. Arrested lesions are brown, hard, and do not require intervention. Active lesions are white, chalky, soft, and progressive. The ICDAS system provides a standardized framework for this classification. In patients with xerostomia, caries risk is substantially elevated, and relevant guidelines recommend intensified fluoride use and saliva substitution.
Mechanisms
Caries development proceeds through stages: biofilm accumulation, acid production from bacterial metabolism, pH drop, demineralization of hydroxyapatite crystals in enamel, remineralization via saliva, and, when the balance tips, net mineral loss progressing to cavitation. The hydroxyapatite crystals in enamel exist in constant dynamic exchange with the surrounding oral environment.
Classification
The International Caries Detection and Assessment System (ICDAS), developed by an international consortium of caries researchers, provides a standardized, seven-point scale for classifying caries severity from sound tooth structure to extensive cavitation. Since its introduction, ICDAS has evolved into the broader International Caries Classification and Management System (ICCMS) and, more recently, CariesCare International, extending detection and classification into a structured framework for personalized caries management.
International guidelines
- DGZ / DGZMK: S3 clinical guideline on caries prevention in permanent teeth, Version 2.0, AWMF registry number 083-021, valid until January 2030
- DGKiZ / DGZ / DGZMK: S3 clinical guideline on fissure and pit sealing, AWMF registry number 083-002, 2024
- EAPD: Guidelines on prevention of early childhood caries
- WHO: Guideline on sugars intake for adults and children, 2015
- American Dental Association: Evidence-based clinical practice guideline on nonrestorative treatments for carious lesions, 2018
Evidence summary
What current evidence supports
- Caries results from the interaction of cariogenic biofilm, fermentable carbohydrates, a susceptible tooth surface, and time, not from sugar exposure alone
- Frequency of sugar exposure is a stronger predictor of caries risk than total sugar intake
- Early, non-cavitated lesions can remineralize; cavitated lesions require restorative treatment
- Global Burden of Disease 2021 data estimate untreated caries in permanent teeth at approximately 27.5 percent age-standardized global prevalence, affecting more than 2 billion people
Why this matters
Because caries is dynamic rather than inevitable, early changes can often be managed before permanent tooth structure is lost. Understanding this process shifts the clinical focus from repairing cavities to preserving healthy tooth structure in the first place.
What remains uncertain
- The precise individual threshold at which demineralization becomes irreversible, which varies with enamel composition, fluoride exposure, and saliva quality
- The relative contribution of specific bacterial species versus overall biofilm ecology in individual caries risk
- How consistently ecological, non-selective prevention strategies outperform targeted antibacterial approaches across different risk groups
DGZ and DGZMK (2025), in the German S3 clinical guideline on caries prevention in permanent teeth, screened over 1,100 publications and incorporated more than 230 studies into their evidence assessment.
Pitts, Zero, Marsh, et al. (2017), in Nature Reviews Disease Primers, published a comprehensive, widely cited overview of caries etiology, epidemiology, and prevention.
Ismail, Sohn, Tellez, et al. (2007), in Community Dentistry and Oral Epidemiology, introduced the International Caries Detection and Assessment System (ICDAS), now the internationally recognized standard for caries classification.
Slayton, Urquhart, Araujo, et al. (2018), in the American Dental Association's evidence-based clinical practice guideline, reviewed nonrestorative treatments for carious lesions, providing an independent international counterpart to the German S3 guideline.
A 2025 analysis of Global Burden of Disease 2021 data, published in BMC Oral Health, estimated the global age-standardized prevalence of untreated caries in permanent teeth at approximately 27.5 percent, corresponding to more than 2 billion cases worldwide.